Remote switching question

The General forum is where users can discuss any topic regarding Motorola communications equipment - hardware, software, etc. There are also several focused forums on this board, so please take the time to ensure that your questions doesn't fall into one of those categories before posting here!

Moderator: Queue Moderator

Post Reply
User avatar
jbxx
Batboard $upporter
Posts: 200
Joined: Sun Sep 15, 2002 8:04 am

Remote switching question

Post by jbxx »

Hmmm, I had an idea last night after sombody nearly
got injured at work yesterday.
What I want to do is switch a 20 A. outlet
remotely by radio ( no power available at the transmitting end).
I was thinking along the lines of FRS radios.
About no more than 1000' distance, but possibly between
floors. Maybe triggering an SCR to a relay to handle the current load . DTMF ? CTCSS ? DIG ? Any Ideas?
J.B. AD6WX
User avatar
motor59
Batboard $upporter
Posts: 422
Joined: Mon Oct 01, 2001 4:00 pm

Post by motor59 »

My first thought-

If this is safety related, do you really want to depend on a system where some 13 year old with a ratshack FRS toy might accidently re-energize the circuit?

If, however - you put the rx radio on the same circuit you're de-energizing, then it would only work as a disabling device. You'd have to manually reset it to get power back to the rx radio.

Of course, you'd have to be willing to accept that some interference or spurious transmission could cut power on that circuit at any time...
"We sleep safe in our beds because rough men stand ready in the night to visit violence on those who would do us harm. "
RKG
Posts: 2629
Joined: Mon Dec 10, 2001 4:00 pm

Post by RKG »

Take a look at the PLC (or "X10") line of products available from such sources as SmartHome.com.

A 20A relay is easy to acquire. In basic form, it is switched by PLC commands over the power line, but you can get devices that will send commands over the air (very short distance) to a receiver that will convert them and then send them over the power line.

Alternatively, you can get "transponder" boards that will listen to DTMF commands and use them to open or close low current relays. You could feed the "transponder" audio from a regular radio receiver. You then used the contact closure of the transponder to trigger an X10 command to be send to the PLC 20A switch via an inexpensive module. Range is now a function of how good your radio equipment is.

I do agree with M59 that you should wire an additonal switch in series with the load, so that the circuit can be locally de-powered in a way that cannot be negated by the OTA commands. That switch could be piloted, so that when the red light is glowing, everyone knows that the device in question can be cycled by someone who is not in sight and may not be on the team.
User avatar
jbxx
Batboard $upporter
Posts: 200
Joined: Sun Sep 15, 2002 8:04 am

Post by jbxx »

I should clarify the application in mind.
I want tobe able to kill a fully loaded 20A circuit.
I was experimenting today by remotely faulting
a GFI with an SCR, works well.
I want to kill a wire pulling machine.
The operator of the machine can not hear anything.
Im talking about pulling say 4 -750 McM in over 1000'
runs . When I want the machine to stop, it needs to stop,
NOW. I want it to be manually reset.
I tried the X10 stuff, but it doesn't have the range.
Over 25 years of pulling big stuff I probably have had
at least a dozen pull failures . Like 10' reels falling off reel
jacks and such, I nearly had my arm sucked into a 6"
conduit one time when a wire surged. We tried to stop the pull,
but as usual, no luck.
J.B. AD6WX ( also known as three fingered J.B.)
User avatar
kf4sqb
Posts: 1493
Joined: Mon May 19, 2003 9:11 pm
What radios do you own?: I can't enter that much....

Post by kf4sqb »

Interesting problem, JB. What kind of wire puller are you useing? I used to work for an electrical contractor, and have been on several pulls where we used the Greenlee puller. Tough little machine. Believe it or not, we have managed to bog them down before. Then again, we have also had them break concrete when they started pulling out the anchors that we had it attached to the floor with.......! If you can make this work, make it portable, and sell it!
brett "dot" kitchens "at" marel "dot" com



Look for the new "Jedi" series portables!

Bat-Phone= BAT-CAVE (2283)

-.- .. ....- -.-. -.-- . .. ... -- -.-- -... .-. --- - .... . .-. .-.-.-
User avatar
jbxx
Batboard $upporter
Posts: 200
Joined: Sun Sep 15, 2002 8:04 am

Post by jbxx »

I own a few pullers/ tuggers. A couple of Greenlees
an Einsley and a supertugger. I have destroyed all
sorts of equipment with the Greenlees but the
supertugger is about a Greenlee X 10.
The Greenlees could not pull 4-750 MCM over 1000'.
J.B. AD6WX
spareparts
Batboard $upporter
Posts: 502
Joined: Fri Dec 19, 2003 5:33 pm

Post by spareparts »

JB,
Consider this - Set it up failsafe. To run, you need the receiver to see the carrier & DPL code. It looses the signal, it drops out the control voltage.

This way if the electronics take a dump, the puller stops & you know your safety system is off line or out of range.

Just a thought-

Martin
thebigphish
Posts: 1477
Joined: Sat Nov 29, 2003 10:10 pm
What radios do you own?: AM/FM

Post by thebigphish »

spareparts wrote:JB,
Consider this - Set it up failsafe. To run, you need the receiver to see the carrier & DPL code. It looses the signal, it drops out the control voltage.

This way if the electronics take a dump, the puller stops & you know your safety system is off line or out of range.

Just a thought-

Martin
good idea, a failsafe w/ manual reset seems to minimize the abberant kid with a ratshack FRS from costing you a limb...
"How do you plan to outwit Death?"
"With a knight and bishop combination; I will destroy his flank.
" --Antonious Block
OX
Posts: 1321
Joined: Tue Sep 04, 2001 4:00 pm

Post by OX »

Have your safety officer consult the OSHA code before implementing anything. You would really hate to have something happen with your contraption in the middle of things and OSHA to start asking questions...
User avatar
jbxx
Batboard $upporter
Posts: 200
Joined: Sun Sep 15, 2002 8:04 am

Post by jbxx »

Safety officer??
Bwahhahahha.
Quite seriously though, all this will do at the worst
is shut the machine down. No possible harm done.
Quite frankly when you are dealing with somthing that has this much power. You don't rely on any safety devices.
Besides at this point there aren't any.
J.B. AD6WX
thebigphish
Posts: 1477
Joined: Sat Nov 29, 2003 10:10 pm
What radios do you own?: AM/FM

Post by thebigphish »

jbxx wrote:Safety officer??
Bwahhahahha.
Quite seriously though, all this will do at the worst
is shut the machine down. No possible harm done.
Quite frankly when you are dealing with somthing that has this much power. You don't rely on any safety devices.
Besides at this point there aren't any.
J.B. AD6WX
i was just thinking? what kind of job-run time will this unit have? if you're pumping out a carrier from a portable while this thing is running...aren't you gonna run into times when you'll suck the batteries dry while the puller is pulling away? From a portable perspective, a job run time that exceeds your available battery capacity will suck..not to mention, portables aren't REALLY designed for extended TX times or constant loads over a LONG time...i mean, a week or so of constatly TXing & changing batteries i think would smoke some finals...heat? decreased TX efficiency? final damage?i don't know, i'm just thinking out loud.


I mean, how often is a portable REALLY pushed past a minute of constant TX? (insert that comment about those moron sgts or lieus who can't shut up) They're not designed for heavy, constant TXing.
"How do you plan to outwit Death?"
"With a knight and bishop combination; I will destroy his flank.
" --Antonious Block
User avatar
kf4sqb
Posts: 1493
Joined: Mon May 19, 2003 9:11 pm
What radios do you own?: I can't enter that much....

Post by kf4sqb »

TX time would definately be an issue. My P1225 hung in transmit for close to an hour one day before I realized it. It still works fine, but it got hot enough that it was rather uncomfortable to hold. If the range isn't an issue, maybe a unit on low power would be acceptable?


BTW, Chris, I love the signiture. Sounds like my wife. Something I am working on will not cooeperate, and I insert the proper expletive, and my wire will invariably ask "what is it"? I tell her to "define it. "It" is a pretty broad subject". :lol:
brett "dot" kitchens "at" marel "dot" com



Look for the new "Jedi" series portables!

Bat-Phone= BAT-CAVE (2283)

-.- .. ....- -.-. -.-- . .. ... -- -.-- -... .-. --- - .... . .-. .-.-.-
User avatar
jbxx
Batboard $upporter
Posts: 200
Joined: Sun Sep 15, 2002 8:04 am

Post by jbxx »

Yeh, I don't want to be transmitting full time.
We can be pulling up to a couple of hours.
FRS/ GMRS sometimes will not even talk
from end to end even though we're talking
say 1500' . That 1500' can be in a tunnel.
By the way, these 750 MCM with 35KV insulation
are about 3" diam. each wire.
I think I might have a working solution.
Audio output through a 2n222 to fire an SCR
with a manual reset. Using CTCSS and 5W.
Just needs a little tweaking now.
Thanks for all the input.
J.B. AD6WX
Bob W
Posts: 142
Joined: Fri Sep 07, 2001 4:00 pm

Post by Bob W »

jbxx wrote:Yeh, I don't want to be transmitting full time.
We can be pulling up to a couple of hours.
FRS/ GMRS sometimes will not even talk
from end to end even though we're talking
say 1500' . That 1500' can be in a tunnel.
By the way, these 750 MCM with 35KV insulation
are about 3" diam. each wire.
I think I might have a working solution.
Audio output through a 2n222 to fire an SCR
with a manual reset. Using CTCSS and 5W.
Just needs a little tweaking now.
Thanks for all the input.
J.B. AD6WX
If you are talking about firing an SCR with a transistor, then you're not isolated. Not good. Try this... A 120 Vac coil DPDT relay (K1) with contacts sufficient to handle machine current. One side of coil to neutral. Other side of coil goes thru N/O contacts on K1 to N/C contacts on a 12 Vdc relay (K2) on to 120 Vac source. Normally open pushbutton across N/O contacts on K1 (this resets the K1 relay if dropped). Coil on K2 is driven by a CSQ/PL (or DPL) output on something like a Maxtrac. Valid code is received, K2 pulls in, dropping K1. Your load is thru the other N/O contacts on K1. All is isolated, you can explain how it works to anyone, and no falsing from noise.

As far as what you've been doing using a GFI as a big one shot relay.... There's a couple of issues. They are not designed to repetitively break big loads - the contacts burn up, and they fail open. Also, if you are tripping it by causing a current imbalance thru the SCR, you need to know that when you have a large balanced load on it, it's sensitivity is likely to be reduced from the couple of MA that it takes to trip it when there's no load. Also, the wierd current waveform from a motor under load changes the picture. Trip level is still such that it will perform it's intended function - trip if there's enough imbalance to represent damaging current flowing thru a human - UL says that's 5 MA.
User avatar
jbxx
Batboard $upporter
Posts: 200
Joined: Sun Sep 15, 2002 8:04 am

Post by jbxx »

Thank you for the good reply,
you brought forth a couple of important issues
that I had not considered.
This is a project in flux, so it will be going through
quite a few versions.
J.B. AD6WX
Post Reply

Return to “General Motorola Solutions & Legacy Radio Discussion”